The short answer
A cold bulk means the whole batch of dough does most of its rising in the fridge overnight, and you divide and shape it the next morning. Let the dough rise 25 to 40% at room temperature first, with folds, then chill it for 8 to 14 hours.
That is a shorter room-temperature bulk than the usual 75%. The fridge does not stop fermentation right away, so the dough keeps rising for hours after it goes in. At 75°F (24°C) with 20% starter, a 30% rise takes about 1 hour 30 minutes. Check your own numbers in the bulk fermentation chart, then work the morning back from your bake time in the sourdough schedule planner.
Cold bulk or cold retard of the shaped loaf
Both use the fridge, but they chill the dough at different points. A cold retard chills a loaf you have already shaped. A cold bulk chills the unshaped dough in its container.
With a cold retard, the dough finishes bulk at room temperature, you shape it in the evening, and the loaf waits in the banneton. You bake straight from the fridge. It is the easier method to get right, and the schedule for 9-to-5 workers uses it for that reason.
With a cold bulk, you shape once, the next day, from dough that is cold and firm. It saves an evening shaping session and fits a schedule where you mix at night and bake in the morning or afternoon. The cost is that you shape and proof at the end, so the bake comes 2 to 4 hours later than a retard. You also judge the rise by eye through a tub, which takes a few bakes to learn.
On flavour, both give a tangier crumb than a same-day bake. A cold bulk spreads that over the whole dough, so the result is often a little more sour and the crumb a little more open. A retarded loaf has a blistered, deeply browned crust. Pick the cold retard if you are new to this, and the cold bulk if you want one shaping session and a morning bake.
How far to let it rise before the fridge
A full room-temperature bulk stops at about a 75% rise. A cold bulk should stop much earlier, because a large dough cools slowly. A 1 kg dough in a tub takes 3 to 5 hours to reach the fridge temperature at its centre. Fermentation keeps going through that whole time, and then slows over several more hours.
If you chill at 75%, the dough will be well past full by morning. The table below uses a starter at 20%, 75% hydration, 2% salt and a dough temperature of 75°F (24°C), with the fridge at 38 to 40°F (3 to 5°C). The room times come from the same model as the bulk fermentation chart. The overnight outcomes are planning estimates, because tub size and fridge shelf change them.
| Rise before chilling | Room time at 75°F (24°C) | Typical time in the fridge | In the morning |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20% | 1 h 5 min | 12 to 16 h | Up 70 to 90%, domed, bubbles at the edges. The safest choice for a long night. |
| 30% | 1 h 30 min | 10 to 14 h | Up 75 to 100%, jiggly, with bubbles on top. A good all-round choice. |
| 40% | 1 h 55 min | 8 to 12 h | Close to double. Shape it as soon as it comes out of the fridge. |
| 50% or more | 2 h 20 min | 6 to 8 h | Often overproofed after a full night. Use a short chill or a retard of the shaped loaf instead. |
If your dough starts at 68°F (20°C), the room times grow by about 30%, so a 30% rise takes about 2 hours. With 10% starter they double, and the dough sits in the fridge for longer before it overshoots. A weaker or slower starter needs a longer warm bulk before the fridge, which is why the starter feeding calculator is worth a look before you mix.
Do two sets of folds during the room-temperature part, 30 minutes apart, then leave it. Cold dough does not take folds well, so build the strength before it goes in. Measure the rise with a marked tub or a rubber band around the outside.
Container, dough temperature and fridge temperature
A tall, narrow container with straight sides makes the rise easy to read and cools the dough faster than a wide bowl does. Put a lid or a shower cap on it so the surface does not dry out. Oil it lightly, so the dough releases in the morning.
Dough temperature sets how much the dough rises before the fridge takes hold. Mix with water that lands the dough near 75°F (24°C). A warmer dough rises faster at the start, and the whole schedule moves earlier.
A fridge at 38°F (3°C) slows things more than one at 42°F (6°C). Many home fridges run warmer than the dial says, and a door shelf runs warmest. Put the tub on a middle shelf and use a fridge thermometer if you can. In a warm fridge, chill at a lower rise or shorten the stay.
How long the dough can stay in the fridge
With a 30% rise first and 20% starter, 10 to 14 hours is the target and up to 18 hours works. With 10% starter you can push to about 24 hours. The longer the stay, the lower the rise should be before the fridge.
Signs it went too far include a dough that has more than doubled, a surface covered in large bubbles, a sharp or boozy smell, and a dough that tears or flows like batter when you scrape it out. Gluten has started to break down at that point.
The next morning
Take the tub out and look at it. You want the dough up 75 to 100% from where it started, with a domed top and a few bubbles. If it looks right, go straight to shaping. Do not warm it up first.
Shape cold. Cold dough is firm and holds tension, so it is easier to handle than warm dough. Turn it onto a lightly floured bench, divide it if you are making two loaves, and pre-shape each piece into a round. Rest them 20 to 30 minutes, covered. Then do the final shape and put the dough into the banneton seam side up.
For the final proof, you have two options. For a bake in 1 to 2 hours, leave the shaped dough at room temperature for 1 to 2 hours. It starts at about 40°F (5°C), so it needs longer than usual. Poke it. A dent that fills back slowly means it is ready. For a later bake, put the loaf back in the fridge for up to 12 hours and bake it from cold.
If the dough is stiff and barely moved, let it warm on the counter for 1 to 2 hours before shaping. Check it every 30 minutes.
Troubleshooting
Dough barely rose overnight. The room rise was too short, the starter was weak, or the fridge was very cold. Give it 1 to 3 hours at room temperature, then shape when it is up 50 to 60%. Next time, chill at a 30 to 40% rise, or use 25 to 30% starter.
Dough overproofed. It is flat, loose and smells sharp. Shape it gently and bake it as a pan loaf, or press it into focaccia. Next time, chill at a lower rise, cut the starter to 10%, or shorten the stay.
Slack dough that will not hold a shape. This is usually overproofing or too much water. Fold it into a tight ball, chill it for 20 minutes to firm it up, and shape again with less flour on the bench. Use a pan if it still spreads. Lower the hydration by 3 to 5 points next time, as in the hydration chart.
Frequently asked questions
Can you bulk ferment sourdough in the fridge overnight?
Yes. Let the dough rise 25 to 40% at room temperature, with a couple of folds, then chill it for 8 to 14 hours and shape it the next morning. The schedule planner works out the clock times.
How long should sourdough bulk ferment in the fridge?
Most doughs need 10 to 14 hours after a 30% room-temperature rise. A lower rise before the fridge allows a longer stay, up to about 18 hours. With 10% starter you can go to about 24 hours.
Do I let cold bulk dough warm up before shaping?
No, shape it cold. Cold dough is firm and easier to handle. Only warm it first if it has barely risen, and then for 1 to 2 hours at room temperature.
What is the difference between a cold bulk and a cold retard?
A cold bulk chills the whole dough before you shape it. A cold retard chills the loaf after shaping. A retard is easier to judge, and a cold bulk saves one shaping session.
How do I know the dough has risen enough to go in the fridge?
Look for a rise of 25 to 40%, a smooth surface and a few bubbles. Mark the tub with tape at the starting level. The bulk fermentation chart gives the room time for your dough temperature.
Why did my cold bulk dough overproof?
Usually it went in the fridge with too much rise, or it stayed too long. A large dough keeps fermenting for hours after it goes in. Chill at a lower rise or use less starter.
