Skip to content

Sourdough starter not rising? 9 causes and fixes

Updated

The short answer

Most starters that will not rise are too cold, too young or fed at a ratio that peaks before you look. Check those three first. Move the jar to a spot near 75°F (24°C), feed it 1:1:1 with unbleached flour, and watch it for 8 hours with a rubber band on the jar.

If the starter is less than two weeks old and bubbles but does not double, it is probably normal. The sections below go through the causes in the order that fixes the most starters first.

How long a new starter takes

A new starter usually needs 7 to 14 days to rise reliably, and in a cool kitchen it can take 3 weeks. Reliable means it at least doubles within 4 to 8 hours of a feed, several days in a row.

Days 1 to 3 often show bubbles. Those come from bacteria that live in the flour and make gas, not from yeast. Around day 3 to 7 the mix usually goes flat and smells odd, sometimes like nail polish remover or cheese. The early bacteria make the jar acidic, and that kills them off. Wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria then take over, and the real rise starts.

Do not throw the jar out during the lull. Keep feeding it once a day, or twice a day if the kitchen is warm, and keep the jar at 75°F (24°C) if you can. For the full schedule, see how to make a sourdough starter from scratch.

Nine causes at a glance

Work down the table from the top. Each row names a cause, how to spot it and what to change.

Common reasons a sourdough starter will not rise, how to spot each and the fix
CauseHow to spot itFix
Too coldFew bubbles, slow growth, the jar feels coolMove it to 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C) and feed again
Starter is too youngUnder 14 days old, bubbles but no doublingFeed daily and wait, up to 3 weeks in a cool room
Weak flourThin, soupy mix, little gas heldUse unbleached flour and add 20 to 50% whole wheat or rye
Ratio too big for the roomLittle or no rise after 8 hours in a cool room, then a slow, late peakUse 1:1:1 in a cool room and 1:5:5 in a hot one
Peaked before you lookedTide marks on the jar, a collapsed top, sour smellCheck every 2 hours and use a bigger ratio
Chloramine in tap waterStarter that is fine on bottled water onlySwitch to filtered or bottled water for a week
Hydration too thinRunny batter with bubbles but no heightWeigh equal flour and water, or go slightly stiffer
Hungry or crowdedGrey liquid on top, leftover starter fills the jarDiscard down to 10 to 20 g, then feed
Straight from the fridgeDense, barely moves for hours after one feedGive it 2 to 3 warm feeds before baking

The fixes below explain each row, plus the cases the table cannot cover.

Temperature

Cold is the most common cause. Yeast in a starter works best at 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C). At 65°F (18°C) a feed can take twice as long to peak, and below 60°F (16°C) it may look dead. The same math is behind the bulk fermentation chart, which shows how much warmth changes timing.

Put the jar in the oven with only the light on, on top of the fridge, or in a small cooler with a jar of warm water. Do not go above about 85°F (29°C). Past that the starter peaks fast and then collapses. Read the jar with a thermometer, because the room reading often misses a cold counter.

Flour and water

Bleached or low-protein flour gives yeast less to eat and gives the mix less structure to trap gas. Use unbleached flour, either all-purpose or bread flour. Replacing 20 to 50% of the flour with whole wheat or rye helps most. Both carry more nutrients and wild microbes, and a starter that was stuck often wakes up within two feeds.

Tap water is usually fine. Chlorine fades if you leave the water out for a few hours. Chloramine does not, and some cities use it. If your starter works on bottled or filtered water and sulks on tap water, switch for a week.

Hydration matters too. A starter at 100% hydration, equal weights of flour and water, makes a thick batter that holds bubbles and climbs. A much wetter mix, above about 150%, bubbles and fizzes but does not rise, because it cannot hold the gas. The hydration calculator checks your numbers.

Feeding ratio and timing

A big ratio in a cool room peaks late. A small ratio in a hot room peaks early and falls before you check. A 1:1:1 feed at 75°F (24°C) peaks in 4 to 6 hours. A 1:5:5 feed in the same room peaks in 8 to 12 hours. If you glance at a 1:1:1 starter after 10 hours, it has already risen and fallen, and it looks flat.

Match the ratio to the room. Use 1:1:1 or 1:2:2 when the room is cool or the starter is young, and 1:5:5 when you want it to last overnight. The feeding ratios guide has peak times from 68 to 82°F, and the starter feeding calculator turns any ratio into grams.

Check how you measure the rise

Put a rubber band on the jar at the starter's level right after the feed. Without it, you are guessing. A straight-sided jar makes it easy to read. A wide, shallow dish spreads the starter thin, so even a doubled starter looks flat.

Check every 2 hours for the first 12 hours of a new schedule. A dome at the top, bubbles on the sides and a level 2 to 3 times higher mean the starter is working. Tide marks above the current level mean it peaked and fell while you were away.

Grey or dark liquid on top, called hooch, means the starter is hungry. Pour it off or stir it in, discard most of the starter and feed it. Hooch is not a sign of death. A jar that is too small or too full also stops the rise, so keep 10 to 20 g and feed that.

Starter from the fridge

A starter straight from the fridge is slow and acidic. One feed rarely wakes it up. Take it out, discard down to 10 to 20 g, feed 1:2:2 and keep it warm. Repeat every 12 hours or at each peak. Most starters need 2 to 3 warm feeds to double again, and one that sat in the fridge for a month may need 4. The fridge storage guide has a wake-up plan counted back from baking.

If a starter that was strong before the fridge still will not rise after 4 feeds, apply the warm and whole wheat fixes above before you decide it is dead.

When to keep going and when to start over

Keep going if the starter has bubbles, smells sour, yeasty or like vinegar, and has liquid on top. A starter that is slow, flat on top or smells strange in the first two weeks is normal.

Start over if you see fuzzy mould, which is dry, raised and white, green, blue or black. Start over if you see pink or orange streaks or patches too. Those mean unwanted bacteria. Do not scrape the surface off, because the colour can run through the whole jar. Throw it out, wash the jar well and begin again with a clean jar and fresh flour.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my sourdough starter not rising after a week?

A week is often too early. Most starters need 7 to 14 days to double reliably, and the lull around day 3 to 7 is normal. Keep the jar near 75°F (24°C), use unbleached flour with some whole wheat or rye, and feed once or twice a day.

Why does my starter have bubbles but not rise?

Bubbles with no rise point to a thin mix, a cold jar or a young starter. Weigh equal flour and water for 100% hydration, warm the jar to 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C), and mark the level with a rubber band to see growth.

Does chlorinated water kill a sourdough starter?

Usually not. Most tap water works. Chlorine fades after a few hours in an open jug. Chloramine does not fade, so if your starter works on filtered or bottled water and not on tap water, use filtered water.

What temperature should I keep a sourdough starter at?

Aim for 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C). Below 68°F (20°C) a starter is slow, and above 85°F (29°C) it peaks fast and collapses early.

How many feeds does a starter from the fridge need?

Usually 2 to 3 warm feeds before it doubles again. After a month in the fridge it may need 4. Discard down to 10 to 20 g at each feed and use the starter feeding calculator for the grams.

Is hooch on my starter bad?

No. Hooch is grey or dark liquid that shows the starter is hungry. Stir it in for a sharper flavour or pour it off, then discard and feed.

When should I throw out my starter?

Throw it out if you see fuzzy mould in white, green, blue or black, or pink or orange streaks. Wash the jar and start again. A flat, sour or smelly starter without those signs can usually be saved.

Related tools

In the Zymo app

See what changed when a feed goes flat

Zymo is a sourdough app that plans and times each stage of a bake.

  • Logs each feed with its ratio and jar temperature.
  • Shows the time of the next feed on the home screen.
  • Reminds you when your starter is hungry.
Download on theApp StoreSoonGet it onGoogle PlaySoon
The Zymo home screen. The starter card reads Feed in 2 h 14 min, last fed 7:10 AM at 1:2:2 and 24°C, with Fed now and Schedule buttons.

Get Zymo

Get Zymo for your next bake

Zymo times every stage of the bake, reminds you when your starter is hungry and scores a photo of your crumb.

Download on theApp StoreSoonGet it onGoogle PlaySoon
Email us to hear when it is out