Skip to content

How to make a sourdough starter from scratch: a day-by-day plan

Updated

The short answer

Mix 50 g wholegrain flour with 50 g water in a clean jar and keep it at 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C). From day 2, discard all but 50 g once a day and feed it 50 g flour and 50 g water. When the bubbles slow down around day 4, switch to two feeds a day.

Most starters are ready to bake with after 7 to 14 days. In a cool kitchen it can take 3 weeks. The starter is ready when it at least doubles within 4 to 8 hours of a feed, three days in a row.

What you need

A starter needs flour, water, a jar and a warm spot. Weigh everything on a kitchen scale. Cups give a different amount of flour each time, and a new starter is sensitive to the ratio.

Equipment and ingredients for a sourdough starter from scratch
ItemWhat to useWhy
Flour for the first daysWholegrain rye or whole wheatIt carries more wild yeast, bacteria and nutrients than white flour, so the starter wakes up faster
Flour for regular feedsUnbleached bread flour or all-purpose flour, or keep using wholegrainWhite flour gives a milder, cleaner rise once the starter is active
WaterTap water left out for a few hours, or filtered waterHeavy chlorine can slow a new starter
JarGlass, about 1 litre (1 quart), straight sidesRoom to double, and you can see the rise through the glass
LidLoose lid or a cloth with a rubber bandKeeps out dust and fruit flies but lets gas out
ScaleKitchen scale that reads in 1 g stepsFeeds of 50 g need accurate grams
Rubber band or tapeAround the jar at the level after each feedShows how far the starter rose

Day-by-day plan

The plan below uses equal weights of starter, flour and water. Bakers call that a 1:1:1 feed. Keep the jar at 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C). A cooler kitchen does not ruin the starter, but each stage takes longer.

Sourdough starter from scratch, what to do each day and what you should see
DayWhat to doWhat you should see
1Mix 50 g wholegrain flour and 50 g water. Scrape down the sides, cover loosely, mark the level.A thick paste. Nothing happens yet.
2Discard all but 50 g. Add 50 g flour and 50 g water, stir well.Often a few bubbles, sometimes a lot.
3Same feed as day 2.Fast bubbling or a big rise is common. This comes from bacteria, not yeast.
4 to 6Feed twice a day, about 12 hours apart, 50 g starter with 50 g flour and 50 g water.The starter goes quiet and may smell like cheese, vomit or nail polish remover. This is normal.
7 to 10Keep feeding twice a day. You can switch the feed flour to white bread flour now.Bubbles come back, the smell turns sour and yeasty, and the rise grows each day.
10 to 14Keep feeding twice a day and check the rise 4 to 8 hours after each feed.The starter doubles or more, with a domed top and bubbles all through.
ReadyStarter doubles within 4 to 8 hours, three days in a row.Bake with it at its peak, or move to the feeding routine below.

If you want less discard, feed 25 g starter with 25 g flour and 25 g water. The timeline is the same. The starter feeding calculator gives the grams for any amount and ratio.

Why the starter goes quiet around day 4

The early rise on day 2 or 3 is the part that confuses most people. Bacteria that live on flour, such as Leuconostoc, grow fast in a fresh mix and make a lot of gas. As the mix gets more acidic, those bacteria die off, and the jar goes flat for a few days.

During the quiet days, wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria that like acid take over. They are the ones that raise bread. Keep feeding on schedule. People who give up on day 5 throw out a starter that was about to work.

If the quiet stage lasts past day 10, warm the jar up and read why a sourdough starter is not rising.

How to tell the starter is ready

Check four things after a feed. A starter that passes all four can raise a loaf.

Signs that a new sourdough starter is ready to bake with
SignReadyNot ready yet
RiseDoubles or more within 4 to 8 hoursRises less than half, or only in the first days
RepeatabilitySame rise three days in a rowOne good day, then a flat one
BubblesBubbles all through the jar, and a domed top at the peakBubbles only on the surface
SmellSour, yeasty, a bit like yoghurt or beerCheesy, rotten or sharp like acetone

The float test, a spoonful of starter dropped in water, is not reliable. A runny starter can sink even when it is strong. Trust the rise and the timing instead.

Feeding routine once it is ready

If you bake every day or two, keep the starter on the counter and feed it once or twice a day. A bigger ratio such as 1:5:5 lasts 12 hours or more at room temperature, so one feed a day is enough.

If you bake once a week, keep the starter in the fridge. Feed it, leave it out for 1 to 2 hours, then refrigerate. Take it out the day before you bake and give it one or two warm feeds until it doubles again. The fridge storage guide covers the weekly routine and how to revive a neglected jar. The schedule planner works back from the time you want bread.

Feed the fridge starter at least once a week. A starter left longer collects hooch and needs a few feeds to recover. See why a starter smells like alcohol for the fix, and the feeding ratios guide for how long each ratio takes to peak.

Common problems in the first two weeks

Most problems with a new starter come from temperature, flour or patience. Use the table to find yours.

Common problems with a new sourdough starter and how to fix them
ProblemLikely causeFix
No bubbles after 3 daysKitchen too cold or bleached flourMove to 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C) and use unbleached wholegrain flour
Big rise on day 2, then nothingThe early bacteria died offNormal. Keep feeding on schedule
Liquid on topHooch, the starter is hungryPour it off, feed more often or at a bigger ratio
Smells like acetoneHungry starterFeed twice a day
Thin and soupyToo much water or weak flourFeed with a little less water, such as 50 g flour and 40 g water
Fuzzy spots or pink streaksMould or bad bacteriaThrow it out, wash the jar and start again

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to make a sourdough starter from scratch?

Most starters can raise bread after 7 to 14 days at 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C). In a cool kitchen, 3 weeks is normal. The starter keeps getting stronger for a few weeks after that.

Do I really have to discard?

Yes, while it is new. Without discard the jar grows every day and each feed gives the yeast too little fresh flour. Keep the discard in the fridge for crackers or pancakes once the starter is over a week old. What to do with sourdough discard has eight uses with grams.

Can I make a starter with all-purpose flour only?

Yes, it works but is usually slower. Use unbleached all-purpose flour. Adding a spoonful of rye or whole wheat flour for the first few days speeds it up.

Should I add pineapple juice, grapes or yeast?

You do not need to. Pineapple juice makes the first days more acidic and can skip the smelly stage, but flour and water work on their own. Do not add commercial yeast, because it takes over and the starter will not behave like sourdough.

Why did my starter rise on day 2 and then stop?

The first rise comes from bacteria on the flour. They die off as the mix turns acidic, and the jar goes quiet for a few days. Keep feeding and it comes back, usually between day 6 and day 10.

Can I put a new starter in the fridge?

Wait until it doubles reliably for three days. A young starter put in the fridge slows down so much that it can take a week to recover. After that, a weekly feed keeps it alive in the fridge.

Related tools

In the Zymo app

Keep a new starter on schedule

Zymo is a sourdough app that plans and times each stage of a bake.

  • Logs each feed with its ratio and jar temperature.
  • Counts down to the next feed on the home screen.
  • Reminds you when your starter is hungry.
Download on theApp StoreSoonGet it onGoogle PlaySoon
The Zymo home screen. The starter card reads Feed in 2 h 14 min, last fed 7:10 AM at 1:2:2 and 24°C, with Fed now and Schedule buttons.

Get Zymo

Get Zymo for your next bake

Zymo times every stage of the bake, reminds you when your starter is hungry and scores a photo of your crumb.

Download on theApp StoreSoonGet it onGoogle PlaySoon
Email us to hear when it is out