The short answer
A starter that smells like alcohol, nail polish remover or beer is hungry. It has used up its flour, and the yeast has switched to making alcohol. The grey or dark liquid on top is called hooch. It is not a sign that the starter is dead or unsafe.
Pour the hooch off or stir it in, discard most of the starter, and feed it. Give it two feeds at 1:2:2 in a warm spot, around 75°F (24°C), and the smell turns back to sour and yeasty. To stop it coming back, feed a bigger ratio or feed more often. The starter feeding calculator turns any ratio into grams.
What hooch is
Yeast in a starter eats the sugars in flour and makes carbon dioxide and ethanol. Lactic and acetic acid bacteria make the acids that give the sour taste. While there is plenty of food, the gas lifts the starter and the alcohol stays low. Once the food runs out, the yeast keeps making ethanol and the starter stops rising and falls.
Alcohol and water are lighter than the flour paste, so they collect on top as a liquid layer. That layer is hooch. The sharp smell comes from the ethanol and from acetone-like compounds that build up in a starter that has gone a long time without food.
Hooch is often grey or dark brown because it carries pigments and starch from the flour. Wholegrain and rye starters make darker hooch than white flour starters. Clear, yellow, grey and brown hooch are all normal.
Smell and signs, and what they mean
Most smells in a starter come from hunger. Only a few mean you should throw the jar out. Find your smell or sign in the table.
| Smell or sign | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Grey, brown or clear liquid on top | Hooch. The starter is hungry | Pour off or stir in, discard, feed |
| Acetone or nail polish smell | Very hungry, often after a long gap or a warm room | Discard to 10 to 20 g and feed 1:2:2 or 1:5:5 |
| Beery or boozy smell | Yeast making alcohol, a little hungry | Feed. It is usually fine to bake with after the next peak |
| Sharp vinegar smell | Acetic acid, a starter that is stiff, cool or underfed | Feed with a bigger ratio and a little more water |
| Yeasty, sweet and sour smell | Healthy and ready | Use it at the peak |
| Cheesy or gym-sock smell | Common in the first two weeks, or when the starter is cold and slow | Keep feeding twice a day in a warm spot. It fades |
| Pink or orange streaks | Unwanted bacteria | Throw it out and start again |
| Fuzzy or dry mould, white, green, blue or black | Mould | Throw it out, wash the jar and start again |
A smell is a hint about hunger, not a safety test. Streaks and mould are the signs that count, and they are easy to see.
Pour it off or stir it in
Both are safe. The choice changes the flavour of the starter and the next loaf.
Stirring hooch in keeps the acids and gives a more sour, tangy starter. That suits you if you like a sharp loaf. Pouring it off removes some of the acid and alcohol and gives a milder starter. Many bakers pour it off when the smell is strong, because the next feed has less acid to fight.
Either way, you then discard most of the starter. Keep 10 to 20 g, add water and flour at your chosen ratio and mix well. The old starter is mainly acid and spent flour, so keeping a small amount makes the new feed mostly fresh food.
Recovery feeding
A starter with hooch rarely needs more than two feeds. Here is the routine.
First feed. Pour off or stir in the hooch, then discard down to 10 to 20 g. Add water and flour at 1:2:2, which is 20 g of starter, 40 g of water and 40 g of flour. Use unbleached flour. Adding a spoonful of wholegrain or rye gives the yeast extra food and helps a weak starter.
Warm spot. Keep the jar at 75 to 80°F (24 to 27°C), for example in the oven with only the light on. Check the jar every 2 hours with a rubber band at the starting level. At 75°F, 1:2:2 peaks in 6 to 8 hours.
Second feed. When the starter peaks and starts to dip, or after 12 hours, repeat the feed. After two feeds, a hungry starter that smelled of alcohol usually rises predictably and smells sour and yeasty. If it still does not rise, the starter not rising guide goes through the other causes.
Prevent it with a bigger ratio and a schedule
Hooch is a timing problem. The starter peaks, runs out of food and waits for you. The fix is more food for the time between feeds, so you either feed a bigger ratio or feed sooner.
A 1:1:1 feed leaves the starter a few hours of food at room temperature. A 1:5:5 feed gives it most of a day. The table gives the peak time from the feeding ratios guide and a rough time when hooch appears if you leave the jar alone. Hooch times vary with flour and hydration, so treat them as a starting point.
| Ratio | Temperature | Typical peak | Hooch often shows after |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:1:1 | 68°F / 20°C | 6 to 8 h | 14 to 20 h |
| 1:1:1 | 75°F / 24°C | 4 to 6 h | 10 to 14 h |
| 1:1:1 | 82°F / 28°C | 3 to 4 h | 6 to 10 h |
| 1:2:2 | 75°F / 24°C | 6 to 8 h | 14 to 20 h |
| 1:5:5 | 68°F / 20°C | 12 to 16 h | 24 to 36 h |
| 1:5:5 | 75°F / 24°C | 8 to 12 h | 18 to 28 h |
| 1:5:5 | 82°F / 28°C | 6 to 8 h | 14 to 20 h |
If your starter smells of alcohol before you feed it, move one step down the table to a bigger ratio. A starter fed 1:1:1 twice a day at 75°F rarely makes hooch. A starter fed 1:1:1 once a day at 75°F often does. Switching that same once-a-day feed to 1:5:5 usually removes the hooch.
Warm rooms speed everything up. The bulk fermentation chart shows how much warmth changes timing, and the same rule holds for a starter. In summer, use a bigger ratio or keep the jar in the coolest spot in the kitchen. The bulk temperature chart guide has more on this.
Fridge storage
Cold slows the yeast down by a lot, so a fridge starter can wait a week or more. It still makes hooch eventually. Feed it 1:5:5, leave it at room temperature for an hour or two, then refrigerate it. A starter fed that way holds for 1 to 2 weeks.
If you bake less often, feed the fridge starter once every 2 weeks. A grey layer of hooch after that gap is normal. Pour it off or stir it in, then give the starter two warm feeds before baking. A starter that has sat for a month may need three or four.
Flour and hydration
Wholegrain and rye flour carry more sugars and microbes, so those starters peak sooner and run out of food sooner. They also make darker hooch. If you feed a wholegrain starter, use a bigger ratio than you would for white flour.
A stiff starter, at 50 to 60% hydration, ferments slower and holds acid, so it often smells of vinegar before it smells of alcohol. A wet starter, at 125% or more, peaks quickly and makes hooch sooner. Equal weights of flour and water, 100% hydration, sit in the middle. Weigh both so that the numbers are repeatable.
When it really is spoiled
Throw the starter out if you see fuzzy mould, which is dry and raised and white, green, blue or black. Throw it out if you see pink or orange streaks or patches. Both are signs of microbes that do not belong in a starter, and the colour can run through the jar even when only the top shows it. Do not scrape the surface and carry on.
Wash the jar with hot soapy water, use fresh flour and start again. A bad smell alone is not enough to bin a starter. Hooch, acetone, vinegar and cheese smells all come from a hungry or young starter and clear after a few feeds.
Frequently asked questions
Why does my sourdough starter smell like nail polish remover?
The starter has run out of food. Yeast makes alcohol and acetone-like compounds when it is hungry. Discard down to 10 to 20 g and feed it 1:2:2 or 1:5:5 in a warm spot. The smell usually fades within two feeds.
Is hooch on my sourdough starter bad?
No. Hooch is liquid made of alcohol and acids that collects on top of a hungry starter. It can be clear, grey, yellow or dark brown. Pour it off or stir it in, discard most of the starter and feed it.
Should I pour off the hooch or stir it in?
Both are safe. Stirring it in keeps more acid and gives a tangier starter. Pouring it off gives a milder starter. After either, discard down to 10 to 20 g and feed.
Can I bake with a starter that has hooch?
Not straight away. A hungry starter is weak and acidic, so the dough rises slowly and tastes sharp. Feed it and bake at the next peak. A starter fed 1:2:2 at 75°F (24°C) peaks in 6 to 8 hours.
How do I stop my starter making hooch?
Give it more food for the time between feeds. Move from 1:1:1 to 1:2:2 or 1:5:5, feed more often, or keep the jar somewhere cooler. The starter feeding calculator gives the grams for any ratio.
How often should I feed a starter in the fridge?
About once every 1 to 2 weeks. Feed it 1:5:5, let it sit at room temperature for an hour or two, then refrigerate it. Hooch after a long gap is normal. Give it two warm feeds before you bake.
How do I know if my starter is spoiled?
Look for fuzzy mould in white, green, blue or black, or pink or orange streaks. If you see either, throw the starter out, wash the jar and start again. A strong smell with no streaks or mould is only hunger.
