Skip to content

What to do with sourdough discard: how long it keeps and 8 ways to use it

Updated

The short answer

Sourdough discard is the starter you remove before a feed. Keep it in a closed jar in the fridge, where it lasts about 2 weeks for the best flavour and is still safe to bake with for several weeks. On the counter, use it within a day. In the freezer it keeps for about 3 months.

Discard is too weak to raise bread on its own, so use it where flavour matters more than rise: pancakes, crackers, flatbreads and waffles, or add it to a yeasted dough. Each 100 g of discard at 100% hydration is 50 g flour and 50 g water, so take those amounts out of the recipe when you add it.

How long sourdough discard keeps

Discard keeps fermenting wherever you store it. Cold slows that down. These times are for discard at 100% hydration, the same weight of flour and water, in a clean jar with a loose lid.

How long sourdough discard keeps, by where you store it
WhereBest withinStill usableWhat changes
Counter, 70 to 75°F (21 to 24°C)12 hours1 dayTurns sour fast, then grey liquid forms on top
Fridge, 37 to 40°F (3 to 4°C)1 to 2 weeks3 to 4 weeksGets more sour each week, a layer of liquid builds up
Freezer, 0°F (-18°C)1 to 3 months6 monthsFlavour fades slowly, thaws a little runny

One discard jar is enough. Add each new discard to the same jar in the fridge, stir it in, and use the whole jar every week or two. If the jar has been building up for more than a month, start a new one.

To freeze it, portion it in 100 g amounts in small containers or an ice cube tray, so you thaw only what a recipe needs. Thaw it overnight in the fridge and stir before using.

How to tell if discard has gone bad

Most of what looks wrong on old discard is normal. Mould is the only sign that means you throw it out.

Signs on stored sourdough discard and what they mean
What you see or smellWhat it meansWhat to do
Grey, brown or clear liquid on topHooch, alcohol from hungry yeastPour it off for a milder taste or stir it in
Sharp, sour or vinegar smellAcid from long fermentationFine to use. Add a pinch of baking soda to pancakes to soften it
Acetone or nail polish smellVery hungry yeastFine to use in pancakes or crackers
Dark grey layer on the surfaceOxidised discardScrape off the top layer, use the rest
Pink, orange or red streaksSpoilage bacteriaThrow it all out and wash the jar
Fuzzy spots, white, green or blackMouldThrow it all out and wash the jar

The same signs apply to the starter itself. Why a starter smells like alcohol explains the hooch and acetone smells in more detail.

8 ways to use sourdough discard

Each of these uses discard straight from the fridge, with no feeding first. The amounts are for one batch.

Ways to use sourdough discard, with amounts and time
UseDiscardWhat elseTime
Pancakes200 g1 egg, 15 g sugar, 15 g melted butter, 3 g baking soda, a pinch of salt15 minutes
Crackers200 g100 g flour, 40 g olive oil, 4 g salt, herbs or seeds40 minutes
Flatbread150 g150 g flour, 50 g yogurt, 3 g salt, 2 g baking powder30 minutes
Waffles250 g2 eggs, 30 g melted butter, 20 g sugar, 4 g baking soda, a pinch of salt25 minutes
Pizza dough100 g300 g flour, 180 g water, 3 g instant yeast, 7 g salt2 hours, or overnight in the fridge
Banana bread or muffins100 gYour usual recipe, minus 50 g flour and 50 g liquidAs your recipe
Tortillas150 g150 g flour, 30 g oil, 3 g salt, a little water30 minutes
Fritters or batter150 g1 egg, 3 g salt, vegetables or onion rings20 minutes

The baking soda or baking powder in the quick recipes gives the lift that the discard cannot. It also takes the edge off the sour taste. In pizza dough and other yeasted bakes the yeast does the rising and the discard adds flavour.

Sourdough discard crackers, step by step

Crackers use the most discard for the least work, and they keep for two weeks in a tin.

Sourdough discard crackers, one tray
StepWhat to doTime
1. MixStir 200 g discard, 100 g flour, 40 g olive oil and 4 g salt into a soft dough. Add seeds or dried herbs if you like.5 minutes
2. RestCover and leave it on the counter. Overnight in the fridge gives a more sour cracker.30 minutes
3. RollRoll it on baking paper as thin as you can, about 2 mm. Thin crackers bake crisp.5 minutes
4. CutBrush with a little oil, sprinkle flaky salt and cut squares with a pizza cutter.2 minutes
5. BakeBake at 350°F (175°C) until golden at the edges. Take out the edge pieces first if they brown early.20 to 25 minutes
6. CoolLeave them on the tray. They crisp up as they cool.15 minutes

How to swap discard into any recipe

Discard at 100% hydration is half flour and half water by weight. To add it to a recipe you already use, add the discard and take out the same flour and liquid.

For 100 g of discard, remove 50 g flour and 50 g of the water or milk. For 200 g, remove 100 g of each. Keep the discard under about a third of the recipe's total flour, or the bake turns gummy and too sour. The baker's percentage calculator shows each ingredient as a share of the flour, and the hydration calculator gives the water if your starter is stiffer or wetter than 100%.

How to make less discard

Most discard comes from keeping more starter than you need. A starter of about 20 g, fed 1:5:5, still rebuilds into any amount for baking and makes a fifth of the discard of a 200 g jar.

Daily discard for different amounts of kept starter, fed once a day
Starter you keepFeedDiscard each feedDiscard each week
200 g1:1:1, 100 g starter, 50 g flour, 50 g water100 g700 g
100 g1:1:1, 50 g starter, 25 g flour, 25 g water50 g350 g
50 g1:2:2, 10 g starter, 20 g flour, 20 g water40 g280 g
About 20 g1:5:5, 2 g starter, 10 g flour, 10 g water20 g140 g

Keeping the starter in the fridge and feeding it once a week cuts the discard further, to one feed a week. The fridge storage guide has the weekly routine, and the feeding ratios guide shows how long each ratio takes to peak. The starter feeding calculator gives the grams for any amount.

When you need more starter for a bake, build it up the day before. 10 g of starter fed 1:5:5 gives 110 g, enough levain for one or two loaves.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use sourdough discard straight from the fridge?

Yes. Recipes that use discard rely on baking soda, baking powder or yeast for the rise, so the discard does not need to be active. Use it cold, or leave it out for 30 minutes if the recipe has butter that should not set.

Can sourdough discard make bread rise?

Not on its own. Discard is starter that has used up its food, so it rises very slowly. You can feed it and wait for it to double, but then it is active starter again. For bread, add 3 g of instant yeast per 300 g of flour, or feed the discard first.

Is it safe to eat raw sourdough discard?

No. Like any raw flour mixture it can carry bacteria from the flour. Always cook or bake it.

Can I add old discard back to my starter?

You can feed a spoonful of discard as if it were starter, but a jar that has sat for weeks is acidic and slow. Keep your starter from its own fresh feed and treat the discard jar as an ingredient.

Why is it called discard if I don't throw it away?

The name comes from the feeding routine. Before each feed you remove most of the starter so the jar does not overflow and the yeast gets enough fresh flour. That removed part is the discard, whether you bin it or bake with it.

Do I need to discard when I first make a starter?

Yes, while it is new. Without discard the jar grows every day and each feed gives too little fresh flour. Throw away the discard in the first week, because it is not yet a stable sourdough culture. The day-by-day starter plan shows when to start keeping it.

Related tools

In the Zymo app

Keep the starter small and the discard jar under control

Zymo is a sourdough app that plans and times each stage of a bake.

  • Works out the grams for any amount of starter and any ratio.
  • Logs each feed with its ratio and jar temperature.
  • Counts down to the next feed on the home screen.
Download on theApp StoreSoonGet it onGoogle PlaySoon
The Zymo Bake tab on the Tools view. A feeding calculator card shows 20 g starter, 40 g flour and 40 g water at 1:2:2, with Hydration and Baker's percent tools below it.

Get Zymo

Get Zymo for your next bake

Zymo times every stage of the bake, reminds you when your starter is hungry and scores a photo of your crumb.

Download on theApp StoreSoonGet it onGoogle PlaySoon
Email us to hear when it is out